Advertiser Disclosure Editorial Disclosure

Milestone Vs. Indigo Card: Read This Before Applying

Choosing a credit card when you have bad credit or are new to building credit can be challenging. There are dozens of subprime credit cards on the market – and that’s before you even begin to factor in secured credit cards.

The Milestone Mastercard and Indigo Mastercard are two popular credit builder options. Both cards are issued through Genesis Financial Services and provide a reliable platform for demonstrating financial maturity and improving credit. But because the two cards are very similar it can be tough to pick the right card for your needs.

Before you apply for your next credit card, check out this helpful guide that breaks down both the Milestone and Indigo Mastercard, their strengths, weaknesses, and the finer points that can help you make an informed decision.

At a Glance

Do Credit Builder Credit Cards Work?

First off, do credit builder cards like Indigo actually work? The simple fact is that credit repair credit cards, like the Milestone Gold Mastercard, serve a vital role in establishing a positive credit history. And this is a role in which these credit cards for bad credit have been successful.

The growth of the US consumer credit card market in the 21st century is impressive. The total number of credit cardholders in the United States is expected to top 193 million by 2023. That number increased around 17% from 2000 when approximately 160 million Americans held credit cards.

Year Average Credit Score
2012 690
2013 691
2014 692
2015 695
2016 699
2017 700
2018 704
2019 706
2020 710
2021 716

The credit score trend rose upward during that period, with exceptional growth over the last decade (as seen in the charts above and below). This shows that Americans have been making better choices with their credit card, despite more cards in circulation.  

good credit habits growth
Credit data courtesy of FICO

While credit builder credit cards aren’t entirely to thank for the improved credit score of the average American, their role cannot be understated. These cards:

  • Provide credit access to millions of Americans otherwise unserved
  • Offer the chance to establish, build, or repair credit
  • Provide entry to more lucrative rewards many would otherwise miss out on

Milestone Mastercard or Indigo Mastercard: Which Is Right for You?

Now that you understand the positive impacts of subprime credit cards on consumer finances, which options are best for you? Both Indigo Platinum Mastercard and Milestone Gold Mastercard enjoy popularity among credit-building Americans – but which is best? Here is the breakdown of the cards over key credit categories:

Pre-Qualification Before Applying

Applying for a credit card requires a credit check. Often, these credit checks (or credit inquiries) are known as “hard inquiries,” meaning the bank pulls your full credit report before approving (or denying) your credit card application. If you apply for a credit card and are declined, your credit score will likely take a small hit.

One way to avoid a negative impact on your credit score before getting a new credit card is by pre-qualifying before you apply. Though they may sound similar, pre-qualification and pre-approval are not the same things.  

A pre-approval means that a lender has analyzed your credit profile based on existing credit information it holds, offering a product you will likely be approved for. On the other hand, pre-qualification means the lender has reviewed financial information from a credit profile and believes you may be a good fit for the credit card product. Pre-qualifications are also known as “soft inquiries,” as they have no impact on your credit score.

Do the Milestone and Indigo Cards Offer Pre-Qualification?

Both the Indigo Card and the Milestone Card offer a quick pre-qualification for potential applicants. This feature makes both cards versatile offers for anyone looking to boost their credit score but afraid they may not qualify due to late payments, bankruptcies, or other negative financial events.

Credit Score Needed

Because both cards are designed for those building or repairing credit, the typical FICO credit score for an applicant for the Milestone and Indigo Cards is around 600 to 640. Both credit cards are available for applicants with credit scores ranging from 300 to 850.

Annual Fees

Annual fees with credit repair cards vary significantly. Cardholders can expect a higher annual fee the lower their starting FICO or VantageScore credit score. As a general rule, expect to pay a yearly fee of up to $100 for a credit card of this type, with some charging significantly higher fees and no annual fees.

The Milestone Gold Mastercard features a variable annual fee of between $35 and $99. Again, these yearly fees will vary depending on your offer. Like Milestone, Indigo also features a variable annual fee. Unlike Milestone, however, some Indigo Card applicants may qualify for a card with no annual fee. Other applicants may receive an annual fee rising as high as $99 per year.

Starting Credit Limits

The Milestone Mastercard has a $300 credit limit. Because Milestone charges the annual fee immediately, the starting credit limit will vary between $201 and $265. Once the annual fee is paid, the credit limit will return to $300.

The Indigo Mastercard has a $300 credit limit to start. This actual credit available may vary depending on the annual fee, however. Like the Milestone Card, Genesis Financial charges the annual fee upon card activation, meaning the starting credit limit runs between $201 and $300.

Rewards

Neither Indigo nor Milestone offers cash back rewards or points. There are no 0% intro APR periods or sign-up bonuses.

Recap

Here is a quick recap of all the features of both cards:

Milestone Mastercard

Lees-than-perfect credit welcome

Quick, online pre-qualification

Variable annual fees of up to $99 per year

$300 starting credit limit

Regular reporting to 3 major credit bureaus

Indigo Mastercard

Bad credit, credit building

Pre-qualify with no credit impact

Fees vary between no annual fee and up to $99 per year

$300 starting credit limit

Regular reporting to 3 major credit bureaus

Things to Consider Before Applying for a Bad Credit Credit Card

Before deciding on any credit card, take the time to think about all aspects of the cards under consideration. Weigh the rates and fees against each other to see if your spending patterns match the card’s profile.

Here are a few issues to consider before choosing a credit repair credit card:

APR

One of the key metrics many credit card applicants consider before applying is the card’s APR – or interest rate on purchases. However, for cards like the Milestone and Indigo Mastercards, interest rates are secondary to annual fees, credit reporting to the major bureaus, and credit limit increases.

Instead of focusing on the card’s APR, focus on keeping your credit use low and repaying your full balance before the statement period ends. These steps will have a much greater impact on your credit health and negate the high APR.

Annual Fee Vs. Security Deposit

In many cases, secured credit cards feature lower annual fees than unsecured credit cards for bad credit. This lower annual fee is due to the requirement of a security deposit (usually around $200) that acts as collateral for the credit loan – and the credit limit.

Because of this deposit requirement, secured cards may be more cost-prohibitive for new applicants than cards like Milestone, Indigo, Surge, or countless others. Before deciding on the right credit repair card for you, consider the upfront costs associated with each option. In some cases, an unsecured card might offer greater flexibility that can help offset emergencies.

Related Article: What Are the Easiest Credit Cards for Bad Credit to Get?

Featured image by Gam-Ol /PixaBay
About: Cory
Cory Santos

Cory is BestCards.com's "Jack of all trades" and resident credit expert, covering all facets of the credit card space. Cory holds academic degrees in both the U.S. and U.K. In addition to credit cards, Cory finds that jogging, cats, and memes are essential parts of a balanced day.